Most studies of breast implant reconstruction count what happened to the implant. Few ask the patient how she feels about the result. A 2026 study from Ancona and Udine, in Italy, did both in the same 56 women. This article explains what it found.

In short

Who was in the study

Riccio, Zingaretti, De Francesco and colleagues looked back at 56 women treated one after another at the Marche University Hospital in Ancona.1 Each had a mastectomy and an implant reconstruction in the same operation. The team planned cancer safety, the look of the breast, the other breast and the patient’s own view together, as one plan. They call this an onco-aesthetic approach.

Where the skin was healthy enough, the implant was placed on top of the chest muscle (prepectoral). A matrix, a sheet of processed tissue that supports the implant, was used when the surgeon judged it was needed. In this group that matrix was ExaShape, a two-layer membrane made from bovine pericardium.

The study at a glance
One hospital, 56 women in a row, at least a year of follow-up. Results are for the whole group, not for ExaShape alone.Riccio 2026, Methods and Table 3.

What patients said

Patients filled in the BREAST-Q before surgery and again at their last visit. The BREAST-Q is a standard questionnaire about how a woman feels about her breasts and her wellbeing. Each part is scored from 0 to 100, and higher is better.

Every score went up, and every rise was statistically significant.1

BREAST-Q before surgery and at final follow-up
The largest gains were in the two domains reconstruction is most often judged by. Satisfaction with breasts and sexual well-being each rose by more than 30 points.Riccio 2026, Table 4. Pale bars: before surgery. Solid bars: final follow-up. All changes P < .001.

Two results stand out. Satisfaction with breasts rose by almost 35 points, which is a large change. And comfort in the chest also improved. That score often falls after a mastectomy. In an earlier ExaShape series, for example, it fell at six months.2 Here it rose by 19 points.

What surgeons saw

Experienced plastic surgeons who were not involved in the operations rated photographs of each result, using a standard four-step scale.

How the results looked to independent surgeons
Each dot is one patient. 35 of 56 results (62.5%) were rated good or excellent.Riccio 2026, Table 6. Harris photographic scale.

The surgeons’ ratings and the patients’ satisfaction matched very closely (a correlation of 0.904, where 1 would be a perfect match). In plain terms: when the breast looked better, the patient was more satisfied. That may sound obvious, but in many studies the two do not agree.

The other breast

24 of the 56 women (42.9%) also had surgery on the other breast in the same operation, to make the two match. Did that surgery, in itself, make patients more satisfied? No. Once the quality of the final result was taken into account, it made no separate difference.1

So operating on the other breast helps when it gives a better match, and adds nothing when it does not. It should be decided patient by patient.

Complications

12 of the 56 women (21.4%) had at least one complication. Most were problems with the skin or the nipple, which is expected with the anchor-shaped (Wise pattern) cuts used in every patient. Most were treated with dressings or a small local procedure.1

Complications, and how many implants were kept
Most problems were at the skin and nipple, where blood supply is weakest. Most were treated without removing the implant.Riccio 2026, Results.

Checking the blood supply of the skin during surgery remains the most important safety step. See assessing the mastectomy flap.

What the study cannot tell us

This was a look back at 56 patients in one hospital, with no comparison group. The authors say so themselves.1 It cannot prove which part of the approach caused the good results, and it cannot credit them to the matrix.

What it means in practice

A reconstruction planned around how the breast will look, mostly on top of the muscle and mostly in one operation, gave large gains in how patients felt and kept almost all implants in place. And satisfaction followed the look of the result. That is where planning effort pays off.

For how the membrane is used, see ExaShape in practice.

References

  1. Riccio M, Zingaretti N, Aquinati A, et al. Oncoaesthetic breast reconstruction after mastectomy improves patient satisfaction and aesthetic outcomes. Clin Breast Cancer. 2026;26(10):134-146. doi:10.1016/j.clbc.2026.08.025
  2. Mazzocchi M, Sigorini G, Cerciello E, Barberini F. The use of ExaShape Bioshield Pocket in prepectoral breast reconstruction: a preliminary experience. Plast Reconstr Regen Surg. 2022;1(2):51-57. doi:10.57604/PRRS-064